94 Points: "This comes from three parcels on the Puligny side. Fontaine Sot is 45 years old, Houillères is 55 and En Journoblot is 60 to 65. The lovely, fragrant nose smells of spiced apples and freshly-turned earth. The caressing mid-palate is sublimely integrated with mouth-watering lift, and it stretches into a decidedly mineral finish. 2023-30." –Christy Canterbury, MW, TimAtkin.com
(January 2022)
91 Points: "The 2020 Chassagne-Montrachet Vieilles Vignes has turned out especially well. Mingling aromas of pear and orange oil with hints of baking spices, beeswax and wheat toast, it's medium to full-bodied, rich and fleshy, with a satiny attack and a long, chalky finish." – William Kelley, Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate (January 2022)
More from The Wine Advocate's William Kelley:
"The 2020 vintage is another very promising year for
Pierre-Yves Colin, who finds the wines a bit more charming and demonstrative than the more serious, structured 2019s—the latter a vintage we revisited in bottle and which appears to possess considerable aging potential. As readers may know, Colin's bigger cuvées are crushed and see four-hour press cycles, whereas smaller cuvées aren't crushed but see even longer press cycles lasting five or more hours. Vinification and maturation in barrel, with a heavy emphasis on larger-format barrels, follows.
As I wrote last year, since moving to his
new, much colder cellars in Chassagne-Montrachet, he finds his wines retain significantly more free sulfur dioxide for any given addition, and he now feels he added more than was necessary—given these altered conditions—to his 2015s, 2016s and 2017s. So, some subtle adjustments have now been made in this regard, and readers can expect the wines to be a little less buttoned up out of the gates than has been the case in those three vintages. Now Pierre-Yves has so much space, he's also thinking about further extending the élevage of his lower appellations: in the next two or three years, he's contemplating fermenting and maturing them in 350-liter barrels for a year, before racking them to tronconic wooden vats for further time on the lees."
89-91 Points, Outstanding: "Background hints of resin and rosemary oil add breadth to the aromas of white orchard fruit, citrus and a hint of herbal tea. There is very good volume to the caressing medium-bodied flavors that firm up noticeably on the firm, sappy and moderately rustic finale. This appears to possess fine development potential and is worth considering. Drink: 2027+ ." – Allen Meadows, Burghound (June 2022)
|